Head to Head Between Carlton and Melbourne

Summary

Since 1980	All Games	Last 5 Games	Highest Score	Lowest Score	Biggest Win
Carlton	33	1	165	43	116
Melbourne	27	4	160	26	109

Games

Season	Rnd	Home Team							Away Team						Ground	Date
2020	R2	Carlton						v	Melbourne						Marvel Stadium	Jun 13 (Sat 4:35pm)
2019	R16	Carlton	2.4	5.4	10.6	15.10	(100)	lost to	Melbourne	4.4	7.11	14.12	15.15	(105)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jul 7 (Sun 1:10pm)
2018	R9	Carlton	3.1	5.3	7.6	7.8	(50)	lost to	Melbourne	3.4	10.4	18.6	25.9	(159)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	May 20 (Sun 1:10pm)
2017	R16	Carlton	4.3	7.5	9.8	12.10	(82)	lost to	Melbourne	1.2	7.4	11.5	14.6	(90)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jul 9 (Sun 3:20pm)
2017	R2	Melbourne	3.2	6.4	7.5	13.8	(86)	dftd	Carlton	2.2	4.6	7.8	9.10	(64)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Apr 2 (Sun 3:20pm)
2016	R22	Carlton	4.5	7.8	10.10	11.12	(78)	dftd	Melbourne	2.2	4.8	6.10	7.16	(58)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Aug 21 (Sun 1:10pm)
2015	R21	Carlton	6.2	10.2	11.3	12.6	(78)	dftd	Melbourne	1.2	2.3	6.9	7.13	(55)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Aug 23 (Sun 3:20pm)
2014	R4	Carlton	3.4	5.9	6.11	7.16	(58)	lost to	Melbourne	3.2	6.7	10.8	12.9	(81)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Apr 12 (Sat 1:45pm)
2013	R6	Carlton	5.1	8.4	12.10	18.13	(121)	dftd	Melbourne	0.3	3.7	5.9	8.12	(60)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	May 5 (Sun 3:15pm)
2012	R9	Carlton	3.3	7.8	8.14	15.17	(107)	dftd	Melbourne	3.4	5.7	6.10	6.13	(49)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	May 27 (Sun 3:15pm)
2011	R20	Carlton	6.1	14.2	18.7	21.8	(134)	dftd	Melbourne	3.7	3.10	6.12	7.16	(58)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Aug 6 (Sat 2:10pm)
2011	R10	Melbourne	1.2	3.4	4.7	6.10	(46)	lost to	Carlton	3.4	5.8	8.12	13.15	(93)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	May 27 (Fri 7:40pm)
2010	R11	Carlton	7.4	9.6	11.7	15.11	(101)	dftd	Melbourne	2.2	3.4	8.6	9.6	(60)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jun 5 (Sat 2:10pm)
2009	R21	Carlton	6.3	12.5	18.9	24.9	(153)	dftd	Melbourne	4.2	8.3	12.4	15.6	(96)	Etihad Stadium	Aug 22 (Sat 2:10pm)
2008	R5	Melbourne	1.3	4.5	4.9	9.14	(68)	lost to	Carlton	3.3	10.6	12.10	15.11	(101)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Apr 20 (Sun 1:10pm)
2007	R22	Melbourne	7.3	12.6	16.11	21.13	(139)	dftd	Carlton	1.7	4.13	10.15	15.18	(108)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Sep 2 (Sun 5:10pm)
2007	R14	Carlton	3.4	8.7	10.14	14.17	(101)	lost to	Melbourne	4.1	9.4	14.6	19.10	(124)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jul 8 (Sun 2:10pm)
2006	R18	Carlton	4.1	7.5	9.7	12.8	(80)	dftd	Melbourne	1.5	4.8	7.10	10.13	(73)	Telstra Dome	Aug 5 (Sat 2:10pm)
2006	R1	Melbourne	3.3	4.9	6.10	10.12	(72)	lost to	Carlton	3.3	6.7	10.9	13.15	(93)	Telstra Dome	Apr 2 (Sun 5:10pm)
2005	R9	Carlton	2.2	7.4	7.8	13.14	(92)	lost to	Melbourne	4.7	10.13	15.17	15.20	(110)	Optus Oval	May 21 (Sat 2:10pm)
2004	R21	Carlton	2.0	7.3	12.7	14.9	(93)	dftd	Melbourne	3.7	4.9	6.11	8.14	(62)	Optus Oval	Aug 21 (Sat 2:10pm)
2004	R6	Melbourne	6.3	12.5	19.9	25.10	(160)	dftd	Carlton	1.3	2.5	4.7	8.7	(55)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	May 2 (Sun 2:10pm)
2003	R14	Carlton	7.0	8.3	13.5	14.6	(90)	lost to	Melbourne	4.3	6.5	8.9	14.13	(97)	Optus Oval	Jul 6 (Sun 2:10pm)
2002	R15	Carlton	6.2	6.5	9.9	14.11	(95)	lost to	Melbourne	6.3	13.7	15.8	21.13	(139)	Colonial Stadium	Jul 14 (Sun 2:10pm)
2001	R15	Carlton	5.2	6.3	12.8	16.15	(111)	lost to	Melbourne	7.1	12.6	16.8	18.9	(117)	Optus Oval	Jul 14 (Sat)
2000	QF	Carlton	4.4	8.8	10.14	12.15	(87)	lost to	Melbourne	3.4	6.4	8.5	15.6	(96)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Aug 13 (Sun)
2000	R13	Melbourne	4.4	5.4	8.6	9.7	(61)	lost to	Carlton	5.2	9.4	15.8	25.9	(159)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jun 3 (Sat)
1999	R9	Carlton	7.2	9.3	13.4	15.7	(97)	dftd	Melbourne	3.2	3.4	5.9	9.10	(64)	Optus Oval	May 22 (Sat)
1998	R19	Melbourne	4.1	8.6	15.13	16.17	(113)	dftd	Carlton	3.3	6.8	6.11	8.16	(64)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Aug 8 (Sat)
1998	R4	Carlton	3.2	5.5	6.9	10.10	(70)	lost to	Melbourne	2.4	5.7	6.10	10.12	(72)	Optus Oval	Apr 19 (Sun)
1997	R15	Melbourne	4.3	10.7	16.8	18.11	(119)	dftd	Carlton	5.0	10.3	13.5	15.10	(100)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jul 12 (Sat)
1996	R19	Melbourne	4.2	12.6	17.8	20.9	(129)	dftd	Carlton	3.2	6.4	9.7	17.8	(110)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Aug 10 (Sat)
1996	R4	Carlton	6.3	15.5	17.6	21.7	(133)	dftd	Melbourne	3.2	6.3	10.8	12.14	(86)	Optus Oval	Apr 20 (Sat)
1995	R11	Melbourne	5.1	8.4	10.7	12.8	(80)	lost to	Carlton	4.1	8.4	11.8	16.16	(112)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jun 12 (Mon)
1994	QF	Carlton	3.1	9.7	11.8	14.12	(96)	lost to	Melbourne	4.4	9.5	14.11	18.15	(123)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Sep 11 (Sun)
1994	R12	Melbourne	4.4	9.8	9.14	13.16	(94)	lost to	Carlton	5.1	11.2	13.5	18.13	(121)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jun 11 (Sat)
1993	R10	Carlton	4.5	8.13	15.20	17.26	(128)	dftd	Melbourne	3.1	5.3	8.3	11.8	(74)	Princes Park	May 29 (Sat)
1992	R11	Carlton	3.1	5.8	9.11	14.15	(99)	dftd	Melbourne	4.1	6.4	10.5	10.5	(65)	AFL Park	May 30 (Sat)
1991	R19	Carlton	1.2	4.7	6.8	10.8	(68)	lost to	Melbourne	3.5	6.7	9.10	11.14	(80)	Princes Park	Jul 27 (Sat)
1991	R4	Melbourne	1.2	9.7	12.10	23.17	(155)	dftd	Carlton	6.6	10.6	15.6	17.8	(110)	Waverley Park	Apr 13 (Sat)
1990	R11	Melbourne	4.3	10.5	14.6	15.9	(99)	dftd	Carlton	3.2	5.4	10.9	13.15	(93)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jun 11 (Mon)
1989	R17	Carlton	6.5	8.8	11.13	15.16	(106)	dftd	Melbourne	0.6	3.10	5.18	10.19	(79)	Princes Park	Jul 29 (Sat)
1989	R7	Melbourne	5.7	7.8	11.11	12.14	(86)	dftd	Carlton	1.0	4.5	7.10	11.14	(80)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	May 13 (Sat)
1988	PF	Melbourne	6.3	9.4	16.5	19.6	(120)	dftd	Carlton	1.3	9.6	10.8	14.14	(98)	Waverley Park	Sep 17 (Sat)
1988	R22	Melbourne	8.2	9.7	11.12	14.12	(96)	dftd	Carlton	3.3	4.4	5.5	10.6	(66)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Aug 27 (Sat)
1988	R13	Melbourne	0.3	3.3	7.4	10.6	(66)	dftd	Carlton	2.2	2.9	3.10	5.13	(43)	Waverley Park	Jun 25 (Sat)
1987	R11	Melbourne	3.5	6.7	10.11	13.12	(90)	lost to	Carlton	7.0	13.2	18.5	21.9	(135)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jun 8 (Mon)
1986	R22	Carlton	4.4	9.12	12.18	20.19	(139)	dftd	Melbourne	2.8	2.9	4.14	6.17	(53)	Princes Park	Aug 30 (Sat)
1986	R10	Melbourne	1.2	1.5	4.9	6.13	(49)	lost to	Carlton	5.5	12.9	17.11	25.15	(165)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	May 31 (Sat)
1985	R16	Carlton	2.4	5.7	10.13	14.15	(99)	dftd	Melbourne	1.2	3.7	4.7	5.9	(39)	Waverley Park	Jul 20 (Sat)
1985	R5	Melbourne	6.6	9.9	15.13	18.13	(121)	dftd	Carlton	4.5	9.7	12.10	13.14	(92)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Apr 25 (Thu)
1984	R17	Carlton	2.3	4.6	6.7	7.10	(52)	dftd	Melbourne	0.3	0.3	3.6	3.8	(26)	Princes Park	Jul 28 (Sat)
1984	R7	Melbourne	6.4	11.5	15.7	16.9	(105)	lost to	Carlton	2.6	4.6	10.11	18.14	(122)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	May 12 (Sat)
1983	R15	Carlton	3.2	6.5	7.9	9.13	(67)	lost to	Melbourne	3.2	7.9	11.12	15.16	(106)	Princes Park	Jul 2 (Sat)
1983	R4	Melbourne	4.2	9.2	11.6	13.12	(90)	lost to	Carlton	1.6	6.13	13.14	14.15	(99)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Apr 16 (Sat)
1982	R15	Carlton	4.3	9.11	14.17	18.20	(128)	dftd	Melbourne	4.5	9.11	12.13	16.15	(111)	Princes Park	Jul 3 (Sat)
1982	R5	Carlton	2.4	4.8	6.15	9.22	(76)	dftd	Melbourne	3.3	7.7	7.11	9.12	(66)	Waverley Park	Apr 24 (Sat)
1981	R17	Carlton	2.2	10.10	14.12	23.15	(153)	dftd	Melbourne	5.4	7.6	14.7	15.10	(100)	Princes Park	Jul 25 (Sat)
1981	R7	Melbourne	5.2	5.4	8.8	8.8	(56)	lost to	Carlton	2.5	5.8	8.15	12.24	(96)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	May 9 (Sat)
1980	R15	Melbourne	3.2	7.7	12.11	15.13	(103)	lost to	Carlton	4.4	8.11	14.19	18.24	(132)	Melbourne Cricket Ground	Jul 12 (Sat)
1980	R5	Carlton	5.3	8.11	12.18	14.19	(103)	dftd	Melbourne	1.3	2.9	4.16	9.20	(74)	Waverley Park	Apr 25 (Fri)

Top 20 Players (last 5 games Carlton vs Melbourne)

Player	MT	Team	K	Avg	H	Avg	D	Avg	M	Avg	HO	Avg	T	Avg	FF	FA	G	Avg	B	SC	Rat	Avg
Marc Murphy	4	Carlton	58	14.5	51	12.8	109	27.3	17	4.3	0	0	25	6.3	10	2	4	1	1	25	456	114
Clayton Oliver	4	Melbourne	40	10	76	19	116	29	12	3	1	0.3	32	8	7	7	1	0.3	0	6	429	107.3
Tom McDonald	4	Melbourne	53	13.3	19	4.8	72	18	28	7	6	1.5	9	2.3	5	5	14	3.5	3	87	400	100
Christian Salem	3	Melbourne	53	17.7	23	7.7	76	25.3	18	6	0	0	5	1.7	3	1	1	0.3	2	8	287	95.7
Nathan Jones	3	Melbourne	48	16	33	11	81	27	12	4	0	0	6	2	4	3	3	1	0	18	283	94.3
Patrick Cripps	3	Carlton	34	11.3	35	11.7	69	23	13	4.3	0	0	17	5.7	7	5	1	0.3	2	8	279	93
Jake Melksham	3	Melbourne	42	14	20	6.7	62	20.7	12	4	0	0	10	3.3	3	2	6	2	1	37	276	92
Max Gawn	3	Melbourne	17	5.7	18	6	35	11.7	10	3.3	110	36.7	12	4	4	7	3	1	0	18	276	92
Matthew Kreuzer	4	Carlton	28	7	30	7.5	58	14.5	11	2.8	95	23.8	15	3.8	10	0	1	0.3	3	9	351	87.8
Matthew Wright	3	Carlton	30	10	22	7.3	52	17.3	17	5.7	0	0	10	3.3	1	0	5	1.7	1	31	257	85.7
James Harmes	4	Melbourne	38	9.5	56	14	94	23.5	16	4	0	0	13	3.3	2	4	2	0.5	2	14	330	82.5
Alex Neal-Bullen	4	Melbourne	37	9.3	31	7.8	68	17	15	3.8	0	0	16	4	1	1	7	1.8	3	45	325	81.3
Christian Petracca	4	Melbourne	42	10.5	39	9.8	81	20.3	16	4	0	0	8	2	4	0	5	1.3	2	32	320	80
Jack Silvagni	3	Carlton	26	8.7	13	4.3	39	13	19	6.3	0	0	9	3	0	0	6	2	2	38	235	78.3
Dale Thomas	4	Carlton	47	11.8	29	7.3	76	19	25	6.3	0	0	8	2	1	2	0	0	2	2	303	75.8
Jack Viney	3	Melbourne	29	9.7	27	9	56	18.7	11	3.7	0	0	16	5.3	7	8	1	0.3	0	6	227	75.7
Kade Simpson	4	Carlton	53	13.3	30	7.5	83	20.8	16	4	0	0	9	2.3	1	4	0	0	0	0	292	73
Sam Petrevski-Seton	4	Carlton	38	9.5	30	7.5	68	17	10	2.5	0	0	21	5.3	3	4	2	0.5	1	13	292	73
Jordan Lewis	4	Melbourne	37	9.3	45	11.3	82	20.5	18	4.5	0	0	9	2.3	8	5	1	0.3	0	6	290	72.5
Angus Brayshaw	3	Melbourne	25	8.3	25	8.3	50	16.7	7	2.3	0	0	19	6.3	2	5	0	0	2	2	211	70.3
Totals	71		775	10.9	652	9.2	1427	20.1	303	4.3	212	3	269	3.8	83	65	63	0.9	27	405	6119	86.2

Please note: Players must have played in at least 3 of the games. If a player has played for both sides they are listed per side.

Top 20 Players (since 1993 Carlton vs Melbourne)

Player	MT	Team	K	Avg	H	Avg	D	Avg	M	Avg	HO	Avg	T	Avg	FF	FA	G	Avg	B	SC	Rat	Avg
Mitch Robinson	5	Carlton	83	16.6	46	9.2	129	25.8	30	6	3	0.6	30	6	7	9	6	1.2	4	40	574	114.8
Clayton Oliver	5	Melbourne	45	9	95	19	140	28	18	3.6	1	0.2	36	7.2	7	7	2	0.4	0	12	522	104.4
Marc Murphy	15	Carlton	216	14.4	160	10.7	376	25.1	77	5.1	1	0.1	57	3.8	25	9	14	0.9	7	91	1517	101.1
Edward Curnow	7	Carlton	89	12.7	84	12	173	24.7	33	4.7	0	0	44	6.3	9	9	2	0.3	2	14	706	100.9
Bryce Gibbs	11	Carlton	157	14.3	106	9.6	263	23.9	69	6.3	7	0.6	40	3.6	8	9	6	0.5	8	44	1082	98.4
Chris Judd	7	Carlton	80	11.4	97	13.9	177	25.3	13	1.9	0	0	39	5.6	10	4	6	0.9	2	38	665	95
Patrick Cripps	6	Carlton	58	9.7	84	14	142	23.7	22	3.7	4	0.7	38	6.3	9	11	4	0.7	5	29	569	94.8
Nick Stevens	7	Carlton	110	15.7	66	9.4	176	25.1	33	4.7	0	0	15	2.1	5	4	3	0.4	3	21	635	90.7
Heath Scotland	15	Carlton	210	14	151	10.1	361	24.1	91	6.1	0	0	33	2.2	10	11	5	0.3	3	33	1347	89.8
Glenn Lovett	5	Melbourne	66	13.2	55	11	121	24.2	24	4.8	0	0	5	1	0	0	6	1.2	5	41	441	88.2
Colin Sylvia	10	Melbourne	129	12.9	66	6.6	195	19.5	53	5.3	6	0.6	37	3.7	9	5	7	0.7	4	46	872	87.2
Tom McDonald	9	Melbourne	106	11.8	62	6.9	168	18.7	57	6.3	9	1	20	2.2	9	6	14	1.6	3	87	780	86.7
Kade Simpson	19	Carlton	278	14.6	122	6.4	400	21.1	101	5.3	3	0.2	53	2.8	13	16	9	0.5	7	61	1622	85.4
Todd Viney	10	Melbourne	135	13.5	117	11.7	252	25.2	45	4.5	1	0.1	20	2	3	3	0	0	2	2	851	85.1
Andrew Carrazzo	12	Carlton	144	12	117	9.8	261	21.8	62	5.2	4	0.3	42	3.5	12	14	3	0.3	6	24	1018	84.8
Matthew Kreuzer	11	Carlton	78	7.1	84	7.6	162	14.7	28	2.5	208	18.9	44	4	17	3	8	0.7	4	52	930	84.5
Brett Ratten	13	Carlton	171	13.2	107	8.2	278	21.4	50	3.8	3	0.2	52	4	7	7	3	0.2	5	23	1097	84.4
Nathan Jones	15	Melbourne	184	12.3	159	10.6	343	22.9	47	3.1	0	0	53	3.5	14	14	10	0.7	3	63	1258	83.9
Matthew Bate	7	Melbourne	74	10.6	55	7.9	129	18.4	42	6	0	0	19	2.7	4	3	7	1	7	49	578	82.6
Jarrad Waite	11	Carlton	118	10.7	57	5.2	175	15.9	74	6.7	1	0.1	35	3.2	10	14	16	1.5	13	109	908	82.5
Totals	200		2531	12.7	1890	9.4	4421	22.1	969	4.8	251	1.3	712	3.6	188	158	131	0.7	93	879	17972	89.9

Please note: Players must have played in at least 5 games. If a player has played for both sides they are listed per side.

FinalSiren.com - Head to Head Between Carlton and Melbourne

Summary

Games

Top 20 Players (last 5 games Carlton vs Melbourne)

Top 20 Players (since 1993 Carlton vs Melbourne)